|
Most religious groups are related historically to other religious groups. When a group develops a religious teaching that is largely a variation on that of a preceding group, it is often controversial whether the variant group should be classified as an entirely separate new religion, or as part of the existing religion. For people involved, the differences can be vast. For outsiders, the large degree of similarity is what is of primary importance, and the differences are a secondary issue.
Conversely, some religions may claim that other religions are subsumed within them--that these other religions are manifestations of their religion. However, the members of the "subsumed" religion feel that they are part of a separate religion, and not part of the "greater" religion.
Open Directory does not affirm or deny any religion or belief system. It classifies and compiles websites. The resulting categorization endeavors to reflect common, mutually agreable views; however, there will be cases in which the majority of the followers of a particular belief system will feel that their religion or other religions are misclassified. In matters such as this, it is impossible to please everyone.
For handling such situations our guidelines are:
A. The Heresy Guideline
For classification purposes Open Directory focuses on primarily on similarity, not on differences. If a religious group claims to be part of a larger group, and substantially follows what the larger group does, then Open Directory classifies them as part of the larger group. This is regardless of whether members of the larger group accept or reject the variant group.
B. The Overreaching Guideline
If a group claims to incorporate another group, but if the other group claims to be separate, and if the other group follows practices that are substantively different from those of the group saying that they subsume the other group, then the groups are separate.
C. The Unexceptional Differences Guideline
If a group claims to be separate from another group yet they follow substantially the same practices and have a substantial historical connection, then they are classified as part of the other group.
At times following these guidelines may cause two or more groups that strong oppositions to each other to be listed in the same category. For Open Directory classification purposes the disagreements between these groups are less important than the similarities between them. For example, if Religion X has a schism resulting in two groups openly and strongly hostile to each other, Open Directory classifies them both in Religion X because their similarity in this regard is more important than their religious differences. |